Discover more from Dark Secrets

Dark Secrets is a newsletter that covers a variety of topics related to true crime, true stories, parenting, teen issues, narcissism and human psychology .

Over 7,000 subscribers

Solving the Gretchen Harrington Case: A 48-Year Mystery Unveiled

Writer

Sep 11, 2023

In 1975, the town of Marple Township, Pennsylvania, was forever changed when 8-year-old Gretchen Harrington disappeared on her way to summer Bible camp. Two months later, her skeletal remains were found, and the case went unsolved for nearly five decades. Recent developments have finally shed light on the long-buried secrets of this haunting mystery.

The Disappearance and Tragic Discovery

Gretchen Harrington's journey to the summer Bible camp on August 15, 1975, ended in tragedy as she mysteriously vanished. Her disappearance left the community in shock, and the discovery of her remains in Ridley Creek State Park only deepened the anguish.

David Zandstra: A Pastor with Connections

Intriguingly, the case had connections to two neighboring churches where the summer Bible camp was held. Gretchen's father served as the pastor of one, while David Zandstra was the pastor of Trinity Church Chapel Christian Reform Church, where part of the camp took place.

A Breakthrough in the Case

January of this year brought a breakthrough when investigators interviewed a source with a close connection to Zandstra's family. The source shared a disturbing incident from a sleepover during her childhood, where she awoke to inappropriate behavior by Zandstra. Even more disturbing was Zandstra's daughter's response, suggesting a pattern of such behavior by her father.

The source also recalled a classmate who narrowly escaped two kidnapping attempts in 1975, suspecting Zandstra's involvement. A diary entry from that period corroborated these suspicions.

Zandstra's Confession

In July of this year, investigators located David Zandstra in Marietta, Georgia. Initially denying knowledge of Gretchen's disappearance, Zandstra eventually confessed. He admitted to offering Gretchen a ride and taking her to a wooded area, where a tragic event unfolded when she refused his demands.

Pursuing Justice

Pennsylvania State Police Lt. Jonathan Sunderlin emphasized that "Justice does not have an expiration date." Zandstra's extradition to Pennsylvania is pending, and authorities are concerned about the possibility of additional crimes. A DNA sample has been obtained for analysis, and anyone with information about Zandstra's activities is urged to come forward.

The resolution of the Gretchen Harrington case serves as a testament to the persistence of law enforcement and the pursuit of justice, offering a measure of closure to a community haunted by a decades-old mystery.

Subscribe Psychology Today Publication

Dark Secrets